The Christian Men’s TableFor the Skeptic
Honest questions about God and Christianity · 1 of 10

I am a good person. Why do I need Christianity?

Why a decent life still leaves the question of forgiveness and a relationship with God.

The honest question

I love my family, work hard, and help people. My life has meaning. Why do I need Christianity?

A Christian answer, step by step

Recognize the good in people

People who do not believe in God can be honest, generous, brave, and happy. Christians should recognize that. The Bible teaches that people have great worth and also do wrong. Having a good life does not mean someone is secretly miserable. Having a hard life does not mean someone is worse than everyone else.

Being decent and being forgiven are different

A person can do good without believing in God. But Christianity asks another question: Have we wronged the God who made us? To answer that, we must first consider whether God exists and what He asks of us. Simply quoting the Bible will not settle the question for someone who does not yet trust it.

Good deeds do not erase a wrong

Suppose a man betrays his wife and later helps a neighbor. Helping the neighbor is good, but it does not repair his marriage. He still needs to face the betrayal and seek forgiveness. Christians believe our relationship with God also needs repair. That argument matters only if there really is a God to whom we are responsible.

What Jesus offers

The gospel is the good news that Jesus died for our sins and rose from the dead. He offers forgiveness and new life. We receive salvation by turning from sin and trusting Him. We cannot earn it by doing enough good things. Good works should grow out of faith, like fruit growing from a living tree.

A fair follow-up question

Are you inventing a problem so that you can sell me a religious solution?

That would be wrong. Start with what you can honestly recognize: Have you hurt people or failed to do what you knew was right? Then ask whether those failures involve responsibility to God. Our wrongdoing alone does not prove Christianity. The case also depends on whether God exists and whether the claims about Jesus are true.

Read the Bible passages

These passages explain the Christian teaching. You are welcome to read them even if you are still deciding whether to trust the Bible. Read the surrounding verses too.

Questions for discussion

  1. What makes someone a good person? How well do you meet your own standard?
  2. Can good deeds repair every kind of wrong?
  3. What would you need to know before trusting Jesus?

Optional further reading